With all of Kevin's recent (and excellent!) focus on how well founded the the right of arms is on a utilitarian basis, I should like to remind folks that the right of arms is supported by four distinct pillars, all of which are well founded and factually based:
*The utilitarian pillar, which Kevin describes in such detail: that arms in the hands of the people are on the balance an overall benefit, and strongly so at that. (In many ways, it's our weakest argument, it's durable, but not a first order eternal truth and could theoretically change with circumstance)
*The moral pillar: that the right of arms flows directly and immediately from the eternal truth of our inalienable right of self defense and self determination.
* The legal pillar: For whatever flaws you care to mention about our Founders, they did get many things right, and they understood that the closer our core laws were aligned with axiomatic truths, the more durable the thing they built would be. In their wisdom, they directly and inextricably embedded personal rkba into our legal core.
* The historical pillar: Although public comprehension and rhetoric has ebbed and flowed, the simple reality is that we have always been an armed, and free civil society.
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Quote of the Day
From a comment on Kevin Baker's The Smallest Minority Blog; Geekwitha.45 says in so few words what I've tried to say over and over again.
Sore Subject
Alternate Title - Bob's attempt at justifying spending money on more guns or equipment.
Okay folks, a lesson that has been said many times by many people. If you can't carry comfortably, you probably won't carry. This was brought home to me in a very real way due to my recent appendectomy.
My normal carry piece is my Taurus Millennium Pro PT-145 using an Ace Case Inside the Waist Tuckable Holster. My abdomen could not have supported the weight of the PT-145 for very long in comfort. Nor would it have advisable to have that much weight pulling on the incisions. Incisions that were only closed by medical glue, no sutures involved.
I would like to have several different options to carry the PT-145 instead of just IWB. Ankle holsters wouldn't have worked because of the extreme difficulty in bending over but a shoulder holster rig should have acceptable.
Or I could get something that wouldn't weigh heavily and still be able to carry IWB; something like the Kel-Tec P3AT. I saw a couple of those at the Gun Show and was amazed at how light, thin and concealable they were.
So, the importance of not relaying on one system became very apparent. Luckily, I have a mouse gun that I can carry as a back up. It's puny caliber (.25) is not one I want to rely on every day, but it is my "when I can't carry a gun" gun. I pocket carry it and the weight is nearly negligible.
Folks, for those who are married and have to convince the comptroller that spending money on firearms or holsters is a good thing, please use this as an example. Should our safety be jeopardized due to temporary physical limitations or should we have alternate methods of safety available.
Okay folks, a lesson that has been said many times by many people. If you can't carry comfortably, you probably won't carry. This was brought home to me in a very real way due to my recent appendectomy.
My normal carry piece is my Taurus Millennium Pro PT-145 using an Ace Case Inside the Waist Tuckable Holster. My abdomen could not have supported the weight of the PT-145 for very long in comfort. Nor would it have advisable to have that much weight pulling on the incisions. Incisions that were only closed by medical glue, no sutures involved.
I would like to have several different options to carry the PT-145 instead of just IWB. Ankle holsters wouldn't have worked because of the extreme difficulty in bending over but a shoulder holster rig should have acceptable.
Or I could get something that wouldn't weigh heavily and still be able to carry IWB; something like the Kel-Tec P3AT. I saw a couple of those at the Gun Show and was amazed at how light, thin and concealable they were.
So, the importance of not relaying on one system became very apparent. Luckily, I have a mouse gun that I can carry as a back up. It's puny caliber (.25) is not one I want to rely on every day, but it is my "when I can't carry a gun" gun. I pocket carry it and the weight is nearly negligible.
Folks, for those who are married and have to convince the comptroller that spending money on firearms or holsters is a good thing, please use this as an example. Should our safety be jeopardized due to temporary physical limitations or should we have alternate methods of safety available.
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
Common Ground
I am so tired of hearing that we need to move to the "common ground". Usually from left leaning socialists who are upset that not everyone sees life the way they do.
For example, take free speech; now this is a subject near and dear to my heart and most people but to hear some of the liberals talk, we are miles apart. So, what are we hung up on? Well, first they tell me I have to agree that not all speech is "free speech", that some of it is "hate speech" and shouldn't be protected. If I can't agree to that, we don't have common ground.
But that is the crux of the free speech debate; what, if any, speech should be off limits. To say I have to agree to a position to "move to the common ground" means I have to give up my ideals, my principles.
Another favorite is gun control and "common sense regulation". Moving toward common ground for so many of the liberals means we have to agree to their position that 1.)Regulations are good, 2.) We don't have enough regulation, & 3.) That regulations will solve the problem.
Well, no. I don't have to agree to those. I think we can point to decades of regulations that haven't worked, that haven't made a different, that deny average people their rights, etc. How about starting off with the position of excessive regulation versus NO Regulation -- then finding the common ground. To argue we have to start with our current regulations and then MOVE isn't finding common ground at all. It's tilting the argument and saying the other side isn't playing fair when they disagree.
The other aspect is that we may not have common ground. To me the restriction of government power is an admirable goal. If your goal is the expansion of government power....why should we agree to meet in the middle?
We have documents, remarkable documents (Constitution for the United States, laws, etc) that already define what we should allow the government to do. Changing that requires you to convince me, to move me to your position. IF you can do that, then we've found common ground...but it won't be in the middle.
Some positions should be all or nothing types. If the subject is warrant less searches, shouldn't the case be overwhelmingly in favor of that before we start?
What do you think? Am I being unreasonable, should I try to find the common ground?
For example, take free speech; now this is a subject near and dear to my heart and most people but to hear some of the liberals talk, we are miles apart. So, what are we hung up on? Well, first they tell me I have to agree that not all speech is "free speech", that some of it is "hate speech" and shouldn't be protected. If I can't agree to that, we don't have common ground.
But that is the crux of the free speech debate; what, if any, speech should be off limits. To say I have to agree to a position to "move to the common ground" means I have to give up my ideals, my principles.
Another favorite is gun control and "common sense regulation". Moving toward common ground for so many of the liberals means we have to agree to their position that 1.)Regulations are good, 2.) We don't have enough regulation, & 3.) That regulations will solve the problem.
Well, no. I don't have to agree to those. I think we can point to decades of regulations that haven't worked, that haven't made a different, that deny average people their rights, etc. How about starting off with the position of excessive regulation versus NO Regulation -- then finding the common ground. To argue we have to start with our current regulations and then MOVE isn't finding common ground at all. It's tilting the argument and saying the other side isn't playing fair when they disagree.
The other aspect is that we may not have common ground. To me the restriction of government power is an admirable goal. If your goal is the expansion of government power....why should we agree to meet in the middle?
We have documents, remarkable documents (Constitution for the United States, laws, etc) that already define what we should allow the government to do. Changing that requires you to convince me, to move me to your position. IF you can do that, then we've found common ground...but it won't be in the middle.
Some positions should be all or nothing types. If the subject is warrant less searches, shouldn't the case be overwhelmingly in favor of that before we start?
What do you think? Am I being unreasonable, should I try to find the common ground?
Monday, May 18, 2009
It never stops
From Fox News comes the report that "The Denying Firearms and Explosives to Dangerous Terrorists Act of 2009" is back in the news and moving forward.
This is something we need to contact every one of our Congress critters to try to stop. On the face of it, it sounds like a decent idea- keep terrorists from getting weapons. As always, the devil is in the details.
How would the government define a terrorist?
That is the official definition but from the recent report on "right wing extremism" we know that the government will use the classification to address anyone, any group that they dislike. The adage about power corrupting still rings true for a reason folks.
From the report:
Doesn't that cheer you up? To know that some faceless bureaucrat may decide that someone constitutes a possible threat and take steps leading to the deprivation of right? All this before a trial, before a hearing, before any due process of any kind; people can loose their rights.
Although I'm using the "right wing extremist" as an example, this isn't a left/right issue. This is an authoritarian versus libertarian issue. We need to check the power of the government and we need to do it soon otherwise it may be too late.
This is something we need to contact every one of our Congress critters to try to stop. On the face of it, it sounds like a decent idea- keep terrorists from getting weapons. As always, the devil is in the details.
How would the government define a terrorist?
"[An] act of terrorism, means any activity that (A) involves a violent act or an act dangerous to human life that is a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or any State, or that would be a criminal violation if committed within the jurisdiction of the United States or of any State; and (B) appears to be intended (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population; (ii) to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by assassination or kidnapping."
(United States Code Congressional and Administrative News, 98th Congress, Second Session, 1984, Oct. 19, volume 2; par. 3077, 98 STAT. 2707 [West Publishing Co., 1984])
That is the official definition but from the recent report on "right wing extremism" we know that the government will use the classification to address anyone, any group that they dislike. The adage about power corrupting still rings true for a reason folks.
From the report:
Rightwing extremism in the United States can be broadly divided into those groups, movements, and adherents that are primarily hate-oriented (based on hatred of particular religious, racial or ethnic groups), and those that are mainly antigovernment, rejecting federal authority in favor of state or local authority, or rejecting government authority entirely. It may include groups and individuals that are dedicated to a single issue, such as opposition to abortion or immigration.
Doesn't that cheer you up? To know that some faceless bureaucrat may decide that someone constitutes a possible threat and take steps leading to the deprivation of right? All this before a trial, before a hearing, before any due process of any kind; people can loose their rights.
Although I'm using the "right wing extremist" as an example, this isn't a left/right issue. This is an authoritarian versus libertarian issue. We need to check the power of the government and we need to do it soon otherwise it may be too late.
Sunday, May 17, 2009
Sunday Status Report
Greetings,
Thanks for sticking around if there is anyone left out there. I started feeling nearly normal yesterday morning. I actually got out of the house Saturday night.
We had to purchase some additional fish for our tank that we recieved from a friend several weeks back. Our largest denizen of the tank -Frank the Turtle- may be snacking on some of the smaller residents. The divider keeps Frank on his side, but not all the fish on their side. It's difinitely Darwin in Action there.
I've been waiting on a sunny day to get a decent shot of the tank, it's just in the last 3 weeks those have been in short supply.
So, today is church, maybe a little shopping than working on a post I've been trying to complete for a while. No promises, but I hope to have it ready for Monday.
Updates to follow during the day
Thanks for sticking around if there is anyone left out there. I started feeling nearly normal yesterday morning. I actually got out of the house Saturday night.
We had to purchase some additional fish for our tank that we recieved from a friend several weeks back. Our largest denizen of the tank -Frank the Turtle- may be snacking on some of the smaller residents. The divider keeps Frank on his side, but not all the fish on their side. It's difinitely Darwin in Action there.
I've been waiting on a sunny day to get a decent shot of the tank, it's just in the last 3 weeks those have been in short supply.
So, today is church, maybe a little shopping than working on a post I've been trying to complete for a while. No promises, but I hope to have it ready for Monday.
Updates to follow during the day
Thursday, May 14, 2009
Recovery
For some reason, I didn't feel up to doing much today.
Seriously, the recovery is going well. Hopefully, I'll be back up to full speed tomorrow.
Thanks for all the kind thoughts and prayers
Seriously, the recovery is going well. Hopefully, I'll be back up to full speed tomorrow.
Thanks for all the kind thoughts and prayers
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
What in the World?
Sorry for a lack of posting but I spent some time in the hospital because of a sneeze!
Tuesday, about 4:15 p.m. I sneezed, not even a hard sneeze, at work and felt like someone stabbed me in the kidney. It wasn't a pulled muscle, it wasn't anything like what I've experienced before....expect PAIN. Thought it might be kidney stones.
My wife and I carpool to work, she works only a couple of miles from me so it saves us gas. By the time she arrived at 5:00 I was a hurting puppy.
So, when she suggested a visit to the ER, I agreed. (Ok, after trying not to the first time).After a relative fast trip through the ER, it turns out that I had an inflamed appendix.
Turns out if you are hungry waiting for the test results, it isn't a good idea to get a snack ot tide you over. It pushed back the appendictomy until 1:00 a.m.
12 hours after the surgery and I was ready to go home. Just made it back from the hospital.
More later folks
Tuesday, about 4:15 p.m. I sneezed, not even a hard sneeze, at work and felt like someone stabbed me in the kidney. It wasn't a pulled muscle, it wasn't anything like what I've experienced before....expect PAIN. Thought it might be kidney stones.
My wife and I carpool to work, she works only a couple of miles from me so it saves us gas. By the time she arrived at 5:00 I was a hurting puppy.
So, when she suggested a visit to the ER, I agreed. (Ok, after trying not to the first time).After a relative fast trip through the ER, it turns out that I had an inflamed appendix.
Turns out if you are hungry waiting for the test results, it isn't a good idea to get a snack ot tide you over. It pushed back the appendictomy until 1:00 a.m.
12 hours after the surgery and I was ready to go home. Just made it back from the hospital.
More later folks
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)