Showing posts with label crime. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crime. Show all posts

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Weekly Crime Beat

This week's Crime Beat takes a look at a case being tried in Fort Worth, courtesy of the Star-Telegram.

FORT WORTH — Lucia Milan was working alone at her family’s store in the Fairmount neighborhood on a Saturday in 2006 when a man came in, counted out 50 pennies for a canned cola and left.

An hour later, the man briefly returned, asking to use a restroom, Milan testified Wednesday. When he returned a third time, he demanded money and then struck her repeatedly with a hammer before she could comply, she said. (emphasis mine)

Let's look at a couple of common misconceptions associated with things in just the first two paragraphs.

First, most violent crime does not involve a firearm. The U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics reports that only 9% of all violent crime involves a firearm. Those that wish to make firearms harder for the average citizen to own are trying to return us to a time when might made right. Here is an average female being attacked by the average male.....who has the decided advantage -- even without the hammer?

A firearm possessed by the female store clerk, and the willingness to use it, could have prevented this attack, this vicious attack.

As she tried to shield her face with her hands, Milan said, the man kept hitting her despite her pleas that he stop so she could give him money from the cash register.

"He didn’t give me a chance," she said. "I tried to put up my feet to get him off me, but he just kept on hitting me."

Milan said the blows stopped briefly after she fell to the floor but then resumed with one strike to her temple, which still bears a scar that she showed jurors. She also showed a scar on her left hand that was permanently injured with broken bones and torn tendons, she said.

Next, that attack shows the misconception that thugs only want money. He didn't wait to see if she would give him the money....so much for giving them what they want, eh?


Next, let's look at the misconception that you don't need a firearm around the house or to carry a firearm.

As the man climbed store shelves to disable the security camera, Milan said, she limped across the street to her home, where her younger sister and brother answered her frantic knocks. (emphasis mine again)

She lived across the street from the store. Violent crime occurs most frequently near a person's home. Very few violent crimes occur more than 50 miles from a person's home. So carrying at home or at work makes sense. Especially if you work in a retail business like this unfortunate victim.

In 2005 -

  • The location of about a quarter of incidents of violent crime was at or near the victim's home. Among common locales for violent crimes were on streets other than those near the victim's home (19%), at school (12%), or at a commercial establishment (8%).

  • For violent crime, about half occurred within a mile from home and 76% within five miles. Only 4% of victims of violent crime reported that the crime took place more than fifty miles from their home.

  • Of victims of violent crime, 22% were involved in some form of leisure activity away from home at the time of their victimization, 22% said they were at home, and another 20% mentioned they were at work or traveling to or from work when the crime occurred.

So, tell me again why it makes sense to make it HARDER for the average person to keep and bear arms? Did the lack of a firearm prevent this thug from savagely attacking the store clerk?

Was she better off with or without a firearm? Did just complying with the demands of a violent thug keep her safer?


I realize this is an anecdote, and the plural of anecdote isn't data but in the long run aren't we talking about individual rights?


By the way, here is the current crime map for the area of the attack. Doesn't appear this is an isolated incident. Here is the link to the crime map



By the way, the attack took place in the area where my wife works.

Please join the discussion



Thursday, July 2, 2009

Debunking availability pt 4

Tell me again how firearms are making America the "most violent" developed country?

Tell me again how gun control will reduce violence.

Britain's violent crime record is worse than any other country in the European union, it is revealed today.

Official crime figures show the UK also has a worse rate for all types of violence than the U.S. and even South Africa - widely considered one of the world's most dangerous countries.

United Kingdom - worse rate for all types of VIOLENCE than the USA. United Kingdom with just about every imaginable gun control law...and it is more violent than America...how is that possible.

In the UK, there are 2,034 offences per 100,000 people, way ahead of second-placed Austria with a rate of 1,677.
The U.S. has a violence rate of 466 crimes per 100,000 residents, Canada 935, Australia 92 and South Africa 1,609.
Not just a little more violent....but over 4 times as violent as the gun filled USA.
In Britain, an affray is considered a violent crime, while in other countries it will only be logged if a person is physically injured.
In America, it is considered to be simple assault so the numbers are a fair comparison. Since these are rates per 100,000 people, it is also a fair comparison.


As I've said repeatedly, it isn't the tool that makes the difference. Let's work on reducing the causes of violent crime, let's work on keeping those who commit violent crimes in prison, let's work on letting people be able legally defend themselves without myriad of hassles to do so.

Those things will reduce violent crime, not gun control.
(h/t to SayUncle)

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Bad Advice for homeowners?

I think we've all heard the bad advice -- from just giving them what they want to people advising women to run out of the house during a burglary/rape instead of defending themselves with firearms.

A story in the Dallas Morning News shows just how bad that advice is -- in many ways
(free registration required)


A woman and her 8-year-old nephew were robbed and briefly kidnapped after a home invasion in Far Northeast Dallas on Wednesday morning, according to a police report.

"My nephew woke me up and told me someone was robbing the house," said Robertson, 39. "It took me a minute to get acclimated." (emphasis mine)

Police were called to the scene after the woman's mother, Dorothy Robertson, 61, said she woke up in the house to discover the back door kicked in, the living room ransacked and her family missing.
Get that, the 8 year old nephew woke up the home owner. Should she run out and try to make sure he keeps up, leave him behind, tell him to hide? In the meantime, while she is trying to process what is happening, the crooks are moving around inside the house.

So, Mom's asleep in another room....should the home owner run and leave the mom to fend for herself? Try to manage getting herself, nephew and mom out of the house?

Also note that she didn't call 911. I think this happens frequently from the reports I've read. People don't want to bother the police until they know something is wrong...by then it is too late

If she tries to run....how will she know where the burglar(s) are?

Two men burst into accountant Stacie Robertson's house on Cherry Tree Drive between 8:30 and 9 a.m., according to Robertson and a Dallas police report

When Robertson entered her living room, she said, she encountered a man about 5 feet 5 inches tall, with his face wrapped in a white shirt and a stocking cap. He was armed with a hunting knife and a hammer, she said.
Doesn't that qualify as an armed robbery?
The crook has a weapon that must be used in close proximity (hammer) and a knife that can be thrown (most people don't know how to correctly throw a knife) or used in close proximity. A person with a firearm in the home definitely has the advantage in cases like this.

Legal restrictions that make it harder for criminals to get firearms invariably impact the law abiding owner more. The people who want to restrict firearms seem to find this scenario acceptable -- a female matched against a male will usually lose.
The man punched Robertson in the head, knocking her unconscious, she said.
I'm not saying that a firearm could have prevented this, the home owner would have still have to have the mindset and willingness to use the firearm. When I hear "bumps in the night" I do take a firearm to investigate...would the home owner have done that? I don't know.
I do know most crooks armed with a knife would be less likely to try to punch an armed homeowner.


After their belongings had been taken, Robertson said, the shorter of the two men came back inside and asked if she had any cash. She didn't. "He said, 'Wrong answer,' " she recalled.
At this point, the home owner is dependent on the whims of the burglar...luckily for her, they were after money.

The man untied Robertson and let her put on sweatpants under her nightgown, then forced her and her nephew into her mother's Honda Civic and told her to drive to a nearby ATM, she said.
Robertson said she drove to two nearby ATMs as the man held a knife to her throat and threatened to mutilate her nephew. She said she withdrew $400 from each machine with her and her mother's debit cards and handed it to her kidnapper.
Notice that this didn't take place at night, it wasn't an out of the way location. Looking at Google Map street view, I'm struck by how much this area looks like my neighborhood. Quiet tree lined residential street. Most people were either at work or in their houses to avoid the heat.


My take away from looking at this story? In no particular order
1. Believe your nephew/kids -- unless they have a history of lying, treat a report of an home invasion seriously.
2. Call the police or have someone ready to call the police. Rather have to call them back and report it was a cat on the porch than to go through what these people went through.
3. If possible, put alarms on the entry points. Doesn't have to be monitored alarms, but something to give more warning, possibly alert the neighbors, and definitely make the bad guys think twice about continuing.
4. Don't depend on your neighbors to hear something or come investigate even if they do. The neighbors may not be home, may not think it out of the ordinary.
5. Be armed. A shotgun or handgun trumps a knife or hammer -- if you have the willingness to use the firearm. You don't have to use the firearm, just be ready to IF you have to.



I think the last point is most important, don't you?


Please join the discussion.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

Crime beat update

An update from Tuesday's Crime beat post, from the Fort Worth Star Telegram.

An arrest has been made in the bludgeoning murder of Mitchell Batie.

FORT WORTH — A 32-year-old man faces a murder charge in the death of a 30-year-old co-worker whose body was found in the front yard of an Arlington Heights home Sunday. Thomas Zakra Jackson, who was arrested Thursday afternoon, remained in the Mansfield Jail on Friday with bail set at $100,000. Investigators say Jackson beat Mitchell Batie with a pipe during an argument that began inside Batie’s home in the 5600 block of Birchman Avenue. Homicide Sgt. J.D. Thornton said the two men, both part-time musicians who had worked together in a warehouse, had been drinking together. The fight reportedly started after Batie insulted Jackson’s rapping, Thornton said.— Deanna Boyd

This seems to confirm the statement made by Tamyka in the comments on the post.


Tamyka said...

I'm a close friend of Mitchell Batie. The man in the 'non-firearm' story. He was killed by a man he knew and recently hooked the guy up with a job where he worked. They were hanging out all day Saturday. At some point saturday night they got into a fight and Mitchell did a number on the guy. So in retiliation the guy came back with a friend and jumped Mitchell. Beating him in the head with a pipe and left him for dead. He leaves behind two boys ages 5 and 3. Our kids are the same age and played together all the time. It was my stepfather that found his body around 1am sunday morning. He was a close friend of the family and will be greatly missed. Great father and good all around person. He always tried to see the good in people no matter how screwed up they may be.


Have you noticed how the media isn't calling it a "pipe violence" incident....or a "drinking violence" incident.

I am glad the suspect has been caught, I hope that he will have a speedy and fair trial . And if convicted receives a long prison sentence to think about how took the life of another person.

Should the previous fight be a mitigating factor for the defense or should it be used to point out how the assailant planned revenge and that makes it an aggravated offense?

Would this murder be any more tragic, any more or less of a crime if the assailant had used a firearms?

Please leave a comment



Friday, June 26, 2009

Shared Responsibility

UPDATE at the bottom-- Mike B gets his feelings all hurt in the comments and I take his comment apart. 6-27-09

Over at MikeB's place he is having one of his usual gun crime of the day posts.

As is his norm, he's trying to spread the responsibility for some thugs shooting to everyone as much as possible.

Here is part of the story he is talking about

A 19-year-old Las Vegas man accepted a plea deal today in the case of a drive-by shooting that left a high school freshman dead.

Authorities said Williams drove a car while his passenger, 17-year-old Gerald Davison, shot and killed Privett as he and three friends walked home from Palo Verde High School.

In a police report, it was revealed that before the shooting, Privett and his friends got into an argument with a girl riding in Williams’ car. She told police Privett flashed a gang sign at the car, prompting Davison to shoot at them.

First, note that the victim flashed a gang sign..likely that the victim and the criminals were members of gangs. Hardly upstanding law abiding, honor students and choir boys and girls....but that is a subject for another day.

MikeB always tries to argue that as gun owners we share in the responsibility for criminal actions like this shooting. Why, you ask? Because we own gun and do not cooperate with the gun banners to remove guns from the streets.

Simply because we own firearm and don't work to pass every restrictive laws...we share responsibilty. Once again, that URL is http://mikeb302000.blogspot.com/.

But something he said in the postcaught my eye. See if you see the logical inconsistency in his argument.

From the original post

What's interesting to me is the shared responsibility. Apparently the courts felt the older teenager who passed the gun to Davison shared in the guilt for this murder. What about the girl? The story says there was a girl in the car as well who had gotten in an argument with the dead boy earlier in the day. Does she not share in the responsibility?

Maybe there's only so much guilt to go around. Direct involvement like passing the murder weapon immediately before the incident counts, but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed. In which case, whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation.
Okay, I figure everyone got it but to make sure...here is the sentence that undermines his entire argument for our responsibility


but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed.

So, a person merely sitting in the car but knowing what is about to happen, a person who apparently does nothing to stop the crime -- is too far removed from the responsibility for the murder.

Doesn't that statement means those of us who are law abiding gun owners who don't know the criminals, who didn't break the law to sell them fireams (if any laws were broken) -- are even further removed from the responsibility in the crime?

If, as MikeB say that " In which case,whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation" than how can our responsibility be anything but so far removed as to be
NON-EXISTENT??


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Update -My reponse to MikeB's comment
MikeB,

What an absolute hypocrite you are
Bob, The repetition of the words "child pornography" by you and all your friends is becoming a bit too much for me now.
You've repeated your accusation that we are responsible for any and all firearm related crime for months now. Then when we point out an valid analogy you get pissy.
Sorry. I'm trying to discuss a sliding scale of responsibility about gun violence that I believe in and keep providing evidence and illustrations to back it up.
No, you aren't willing to provide evidence to back it up. We are trying to discuss the sliding scale of responsibility but YOU will not discuss it. You avoid it and will not take ownership of a crime when you expect us to take ownership of a crime.What utter and total hypocrisy. I'm not surprised but to have you get your nose out of joint when you've slandered gun owners for months is disgusting.
You guys respond with an accusation that you don't believe in, not because you think it's so valid a comparison and necessary to make your point, but because you know I don't like it.
If you believe that if I am responsible for gun crime, then you are responsible for child porn.

Second, it is an absolutely valid comparison.

Third, how does it feel to have people make accusations about you that you don't like?

You've done this and MORE, repeatedly and without cease for almost as long as I've been reading your blog. We've explained, we've provided proof, we've provided illustrations, we've provided moral & legal arguments against your viewpoint and you low life piece of garbage have continued to make the accusations against us.

Then you have the absolute gall to try to tell me what I believe and don't believe. You have the arrogance to try to dictate what argument I should and shouldn't make...especially because it might or is hurting your little feelings!!!
And I guess some of you think you can smear my name by repeating it over and over again.
No more or no less then you are smearing the names of my friends, my family, my fellow bloggers by repeating your "theory" over and over again. Fair is fair, isn't it MikeyBoy?
It's not a very admirable arguing method. It speaks volumes for you guys and for your argument
It isn't very admirable of you to continue to accuse us....but then avoiding answering the countering argument.

That is the purpose of the argument....to make you show WHY you aren't responsible for child porn-- something you've failed to do REPEATEDLY. You've just have gotten all BUTT HURT and snippy because I have found a counter to your argument.

YOU DON'T LIKE THE ARGUMENT MIKEB? PROVE IT TO BE INVALID.

Of course, the minute you prove you aren't responsible for the criminal actions of those producing child porn, you also prove we aren't responsible for the criminals misuse of firearms.


SO EITHER PROVE IT OR STOP WHINING LIKE A PRISSY 5 YEAR OLD.

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Daily Crime Beat

From a local daily rag we have the following crime reports

First up - an example that you never know when or where violence can happen. Friends get together, go out and enjoy themselves and drop off the victim behind a restaurant to get his car.


“He and some friends got there Saturday night and went to a nearby restaurant,” Bedford police Lt. Kirk Roberts said Monday. “They all left but they came back and dropped him off.”
The parking lot is used by a nearby office building, police said.
“As he was about to put the key in his vehicle, someone yelled “Hey man”,” Roberts said.
That’s when the man turned and the assault started, police said.

I know that area, it is part of a small row of restaurants and shops...not a bad neighborhood.

A Euless man was knocked unconscious and lay in a parking lot for several hours early Sunday after robbers repeatedly kicked and punched him during a holdup, police said Monday.
At one point, the 29-year-old man who police did not identify pleaded for his life when one of the bandits pulled a pistol out, but the victim passed out before any shots were fired, police said.

Notice that even when the thugs had what they wanted, his life was still in danger. So much for just giving them what they want and you won't be hurt, eh?

Next, in another local city a violent death that didn't use a firearm. I am surprised it even made the newspaper. Guess Fort Worth is small enough they still have to print some non-firearm related crime.


FORT WORTH -- Police are investigating the slaying of a 30-year-old man found dead in his front yard early Sunday.
Officers discovered the body of Mitchell Batie shortly after 1 a.m. after being summoned to the 5600 block of Birchman Avenue on a report of a man lying in a front yard.
The Tarrant County medical examiner's office has ruled Batie died from blunt force trauma to the head.


I'll try to follow the story to see how it works out. Remember to be careful around your home, most crime does happen within a mile of your residence.

Now a little good news from yet a third local city. The police make an arrest an a recent murder.

ARLINGTON -- Police have arrested a man in the shooting death of 19-year-old Grand Prairie man at an east Arlington apartment complex.
Jason Armahn Bernard, 22, of Mansfield was taken into custody shortly before 11 a.m. Monday. He faces a charge of murder, Arlington police said.
Bernard is being held at the Arlington jail on bail of $100,000.


I wonder if the person who committed this murder was a legal, law abiding gun owner as is so often claimed.

Bernard has a criminal history including felon charges in Illinois and Louisiana, according to the arrest warrant.

Oops, guess he wasn't a choir boy after all. Felony convictions means that he lost his right to keep and bear arms. It doesn't say if the firearm used was carried concealed or not, but I would assume it was. Since you can't get a concealed carry permit with a felony conviction, that would have been another crime.

So, was this just an ordinary citizen being victimized or was there a reason for the crime?

According to an arrest warrant affidavit, Bernard, also known as “JDUB”, shot Devion Harris multiple times in the chest with a .357 Magnum on June 15 after Harris and his friends attempted to rob him of cash and ecstasy pills.
Harris was armed with a .22-caliber handgun during robbery attempt, according to the affidavit.
One of Harris’ friends had known Bernard through previous drug transactions, according to the affidavit.
 Drug related crime-- maybe instead of trying to restrict the flow of firearms the nation can try to restrict this flow of illegal drugs. If only there was a decades long effort to eradicate the problem of illegal drugs, we might not have these problems today.


From today's crime report, we learn the importance of situational awareness and the insanity of forcing people to disarm if they are in bars. In Texas, if an establishment derives 51% of its income from alcohol sold to be consumed on premise, it is illegal to carry concealed in that establishment. Even if you aren't drinking, you can't carry.

We also learn that contrary to some people's ideas, crime can happen at home. It pays to be prepared.

And lastly, we learn that criminal aren't going to obey the laws.

Shouldn't we focus our efforts on stopping the criminals instead of the tools? 1 crime was non-firearm, a firearm was used to threaten in the second -- but not to assault the man and in the third the thug wasn't in legal possession of a firearm. Stop the criminal, not the inanimate object