Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Ethics of weapon use by Oleg Volk

Repost with permission -- if you aren't checking out Oleg's work, you are missing much.
Imagine a child playing in a backyard sandbox. The child's parent observes a viper about to bite the child. Acting quickly, he picks up the snake and tosses it gently into the distant bushes. No harm done to the snake or the child. Was that action ethical?

Now consider the speed with which the man would have had to act to safeguard the kid and to avoid getting bitten in turn. The snake probably landed roughly and was injured or killed by the impact. The man used his hands as a weapon to stop the snake from biting and, as a side effect of stopping it, caused it harm. Was that action ethical?

Would your answer change if the man throws a rock, or uses a stick? What about a hoe or a shovel, both gardening tools but used as weapons? The outcome to the child would be the same, as would be the outcome to the snake. Still ethical?

Now imagine that the father was too far from the snake to keep it from biting his child by throwing a rock. Maybe the father is old or infirm and not very good at throwing stones accurately. Could he ethically use a crossbow or a rifle to stop the snake from harming his kid?

Now, let's back up to the first hypothetical. The viper is only half-day to the sandbox, it gets picked up and tossed gently...into the sandbox with the child. Angry, it strikes and bites at once. The same human hands were used as a weapons, but was the use ethical? Would the use of a stick to goad the snake towards the sandbox have been any better?

Tools don't matter. Actions with them do.

Let's imagine another situation, the kind quite common in many restrictive jurisdictions. The same man sees the same snake in readiness to strike. He is too far to reach with his hands, or with a stick or a rock. A rifle would have saved the day, but it is forbidden to him...or locked up in a safe according to the legal requirements. The delay is fatal. Who bears the legal responsibility for the delay? No one. But what of the ethical responsibility?

Would the ethics of the situation change if the threat to the child is not a snake but a rabid, feral dog? How about a rogue human? Unlike animals, humans are presumed to be capable of ethical behavior -- those who are not are termed sociopaths. So a human who knows better than preying on other humans decided to do so anyway and attacks the kid: must the parent be limited to his bare hands in stopping the aggression? For a martial artist in his prime, that may be possible, though perilous. The attacker would still suffer physical harm. Would that be ethical?

Would a stick be allowed for the defender? A rock? A piece of pipe? A sword? A crossbow? A pistol? So long as the intent is ethical, in this case prevention of harm to an innocent, what does it matter if the attacker is hit with a two-pound rock or a quarter-ounce bullet?

Tools don't matter. Actions with them do.

"But we don't mean to disarm the law-abiding!" say those who disagree with my conclusions. Whatever they meant to do is less important than what they actually do. They can only disarm the law-abiding, as the rest wouldn't play along. Moreover, "law-abiding" is not a compliment when the laws are harmful to decent humans and thus not worthy of obedience. Laws that disarm force decent, peaceful humans to choose between putting themselves and their families at additional risk of victimization by freelance criminals for lack of defensive tools (including, in some times and places, even sticks) or retaining arms and risking imprisonment or death at the hands of the law enforcers. Forcing people into such a dilemma is hardly ethical.

Punishment of needlessly violent behavior is ethical. However, capability for violent behavior cannot be prosecuted. Even a man stripped naked, deprived of all tools or weapons, has the capability for violence. He can punch, kick or bite. He kick pick up another person and drop him. Except for infants, people in straight-jackets or quadripalegics, all others are capable of physical violence. The use or, more frequently, abstinence from violence are governed by the upbringing and the personality of each individual.

So how can we ethically justify employing threats of violence (in the form of law enforcement) to disarm peaceful individuals? We frown on armed robbery by individuals, why condone the same when done by groups operating under the color of the law?

Another consideration is the reduction of law enforcement effectiveness in disarmed countries. A person made less secure by legal disarmament would naturally view law enforcement agencies as enemies and withhold cooperation. Without widespread cooperation, police would be much less effective than in areas where it has popular support. Even those who view police favorably are still deprived of effective protection. Of course, legally "police protection" is a misnomer. There's no legal duty to protect individuals, only to uphold the laws for the society at large. Which brings us back to the ethics of depriving individuals of the means of self-protection while providing no bodyguards to compensate.

Providing bodyguards to everyone is a logical impossibility. Who guards the family of the bodyguard assigned to yours? Even assuming some magical source of bodyguards, what of the loss of privacy from having a stranger next to you at all times? In the old days, slaves were used for such purpose -- no one minded the loss of privacy to slaves, as they were hardly more than beasts or pets to the owners. Is that an ethical alternative to simply letting everyone take care of their own security?


"But I don't want to live like that!" Many people prefer to go unarmed. To them, the slight reduction of risk is not worth the effort or they find the armed lifestyle distasteful. That's a perfectly ethical position. Forcing others to do likewise would not be.



Please join the discussion



Thursday, July 2, 2009

Debunking availability pt 4

Tell me again how firearms are making America the "most violent" developed country?

Tell me again how gun control will reduce violence.

Britain's violent crime record is worse than any other country in the European union, it is revealed today.

Official crime figures show the UK also has a worse rate for all types of violence than the U.S. and even South Africa - widely considered one of the world's most dangerous countries.

United Kingdom - worse rate for all types of VIOLENCE than the USA. United Kingdom with just about every imaginable gun control law...and it is more violent than America...how is that possible.

In the UK, there are 2,034 offences per 100,000 people, way ahead of second-placed Austria with a rate of 1,677.
The U.S. has a violence rate of 466 crimes per 100,000 residents, Canada 935, Australia 92 and South Africa 1,609.
Not just a little more violent....but over 4 times as violent as the gun filled USA.
In Britain, an affray is considered a violent crime, while in other countries it will only be logged if a person is physically injured.
In America, it is considered to be simple assault so the numbers are a fair comparison. Since these are rates per 100,000 people, it is also a fair comparison.


As I've said repeatedly, it isn't the tool that makes the difference. Let's work on reducing the causes of violent crime, let's work on keeping those who commit violent crimes in prison, let's work on letting people be able legally defend themselves without myriad of hassles to do so.

Those things will reduce violent crime, not gun control.
(h/t to SayUncle)

Saturday, June 27, 2009

Crime beat update

An update from Tuesday's Crime beat post, from the Fort Worth Star Telegram.

An arrest has been made in the bludgeoning murder of Mitchell Batie.

FORT WORTH — A 32-year-old man faces a murder charge in the death of a 30-year-old co-worker whose body was found in the front yard of an Arlington Heights home Sunday. Thomas Zakra Jackson, who was arrested Thursday afternoon, remained in the Mansfield Jail on Friday with bail set at $100,000. Investigators say Jackson beat Mitchell Batie with a pipe during an argument that began inside Batie’s home in the 5600 block of Birchman Avenue. Homicide Sgt. J.D. Thornton said the two men, both part-time musicians who had worked together in a warehouse, had been drinking together. The fight reportedly started after Batie insulted Jackson’s rapping, Thornton said.— Deanna Boyd

This seems to confirm the statement made by Tamyka in the comments on the post.


Tamyka said...

I'm a close friend of Mitchell Batie. The man in the 'non-firearm' story. He was killed by a man he knew and recently hooked the guy up with a job where he worked. They were hanging out all day Saturday. At some point saturday night they got into a fight and Mitchell did a number on the guy. So in retiliation the guy came back with a friend and jumped Mitchell. Beating him in the head with a pipe and left him for dead. He leaves behind two boys ages 5 and 3. Our kids are the same age and played together all the time. It was my stepfather that found his body around 1am sunday morning. He was a close friend of the family and will be greatly missed. Great father and good all around person. He always tried to see the good in people no matter how screwed up they may be.


Have you noticed how the media isn't calling it a "pipe violence" incident....or a "drinking violence" incident.

I am glad the suspect has been caught, I hope that he will have a speedy and fair trial . And if convicted receives a long prison sentence to think about how took the life of another person.

Should the previous fight be a mitigating factor for the defense or should it be used to point out how the assailant planned revenge and that makes it an aggravated offense?

Would this murder be any more tragic, any more or less of a crime if the assailant had used a firearms?

Please leave a comment



Friday, June 26, 2009

Shared Responsibility

UPDATE at the bottom-- Mike B gets his feelings all hurt in the comments and I take his comment apart. 6-27-09

Over at MikeB's place he is having one of his usual gun crime of the day posts.

As is his norm, he's trying to spread the responsibility for some thugs shooting to everyone as much as possible.

Here is part of the story he is talking about

A 19-year-old Las Vegas man accepted a plea deal today in the case of a drive-by shooting that left a high school freshman dead.

Authorities said Williams drove a car while his passenger, 17-year-old Gerald Davison, shot and killed Privett as he and three friends walked home from Palo Verde High School.

In a police report, it was revealed that before the shooting, Privett and his friends got into an argument with a girl riding in Williams’ car. She told police Privett flashed a gang sign at the car, prompting Davison to shoot at them.

First, note that the victim flashed a gang sign..likely that the victim and the criminals were members of gangs. Hardly upstanding law abiding, honor students and choir boys and girls....but that is a subject for another day.

MikeB always tries to argue that as gun owners we share in the responsibility for criminal actions like this shooting. Why, you ask? Because we own gun and do not cooperate with the gun banners to remove guns from the streets.

Simply because we own firearm and don't work to pass every restrictive laws...we share responsibilty. Once again, that URL is http://mikeb302000.blogspot.com/.

But something he said in the postcaught my eye. See if you see the logical inconsistency in his argument.

From the original post

What's interesting to me is the shared responsibility. Apparently the courts felt the older teenager who passed the gun to Davison shared in the guilt for this murder. What about the girl? The story says there was a girl in the car as well who had gotten in an argument with the dead boy earlier in the day. Does she not share in the responsibility?

Maybe there's only so much guilt to go around. Direct involvement like passing the murder weapon immediately before the incident counts, but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed. In which case, whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation.
Okay, I figure everyone got it but to make sure...here is the sentence that undermines his entire argument for our responsibility


but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed.

So, a person merely sitting in the car but knowing what is about to happen, a person who apparently does nothing to stop the crime -- is too far removed from the responsibility for the murder.

Doesn't that statement means those of us who are law abiding gun owners who don't know the criminals, who didn't break the law to sell them fireams (if any laws were broken) -- are even further removed from the responsibility in the crime?

If, as MikeB say that " In which case,whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation" than how can our responsibility be anything but so far removed as to be
NON-EXISTENT??


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Update -My reponse to MikeB's comment
MikeB,

What an absolute hypocrite you are
Bob, The repetition of the words "child pornography" by you and all your friends is becoming a bit too much for me now.
You've repeated your accusation that we are responsible for any and all firearm related crime for months now. Then when we point out an valid analogy you get pissy.
Sorry. I'm trying to discuss a sliding scale of responsibility about gun violence that I believe in and keep providing evidence and illustrations to back it up.
No, you aren't willing to provide evidence to back it up. We are trying to discuss the sliding scale of responsibility but YOU will not discuss it. You avoid it and will not take ownership of a crime when you expect us to take ownership of a crime.What utter and total hypocrisy. I'm not surprised but to have you get your nose out of joint when you've slandered gun owners for months is disgusting.
You guys respond with an accusation that you don't believe in, not because you think it's so valid a comparison and necessary to make your point, but because you know I don't like it.
If you believe that if I am responsible for gun crime, then you are responsible for child porn.

Second, it is an absolutely valid comparison.

Third, how does it feel to have people make accusations about you that you don't like?

You've done this and MORE, repeatedly and without cease for almost as long as I've been reading your blog. We've explained, we've provided proof, we've provided illustrations, we've provided moral & legal arguments against your viewpoint and you low life piece of garbage have continued to make the accusations against us.

Then you have the absolute gall to try to tell me what I believe and don't believe. You have the arrogance to try to dictate what argument I should and shouldn't make...especially because it might or is hurting your little feelings!!!
And I guess some of you think you can smear my name by repeating it over and over again.
No more or no less then you are smearing the names of my friends, my family, my fellow bloggers by repeating your "theory" over and over again. Fair is fair, isn't it MikeyBoy?
It's not a very admirable arguing method. It speaks volumes for you guys and for your argument
It isn't very admirable of you to continue to accuse us....but then avoiding answering the countering argument.

That is the purpose of the argument....to make you show WHY you aren't responsible for child porn-- something you've failed to do REPEATEDLY. You've just have gotten all BUTT HURT and snippy because I have found a counter to your argument.

YOU DON'T LIKE THE ARGUMENT MIKEB? PROVE IT TO BE INVALID.

Of course, the minute you prove you aren't responsible for the criminal actions of those producing child porn, you also prove we aren't responsible for the criminals misuse of firearms.


SO EITHER PROVE IT OR STOP WHINING LIKE A PRISSY 5 YEAR OLD.

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Gary Indiana Residents, what the world is going on?

I've talked about differing cultures in the past....now we have video evidence of it.


Store Clerk Murdered; Customers Keep Shopping

(Click On the link to see the video)

GARY, Ind. (CBS) ―

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

A Tale of Two Cultures

It was the best of times and it was the worst of times.....and this differently shows there are different values, different cultures out there.

NEW ORLEANS — Authorities say a 17-year-old teenager was charged with aggravated rape and first-degree murder of an 8-month-old child.

The Jefferson Parish Sheriff's Office says Arnold T. Ross was taken into custody Saturday. No bond was set.

Ross was arrested after officers responded to a call of an unresponsive infant near Gretna.

The infant, Da-Von Lonzo, was taken to a hospital where he was pronounced dead shortly after arrival, according to a news release issued by the sheriff's office.

Authorities say Ross told them he was the boyfriend of the infant's mother and the baby fell down the stairs while he was baby-sitting.

Authorities say Ross later acknowledged that he beat the infant repeatedly when he would not stop crying.

Let that sink in for a few minutes, then take a few more minutes to let the rage subside. Here is a near adult, for all practical purposes he is an adult, charged with watching an infant.

So, instead of caring and nurturing the child, he callously, heinously rapes the baby. Then when it wouldn't stop crying -- he beat the infant repeatedly. This is a deliberate choice of actions, both the rape and the beating.

Words fail me.


Then we have a group of children displaying completely different values -- children raised in a completely different culture.

WRENTHAM, Mass. — It took 101 innings, there were 687 runs scored, and 817 children participated.

The players of the Wrentham Youth Baseball/Softball Association between the ages of 5 and 15 played 36 straight hours of ball over the weekend, raising an estimated $75,000 for charity.

The event, billed by organizers as the world's longest baseball game, began at 8:01 a.m. Saturday and ended at 8:01 p.m. Sunday.

Coordinator Jim Lucas says the post-game handshake took about 10 minutes.

The money, which was still being counted Monday morning, will go to a number of charities, including Curt's Pitch for ALS and the March of Dimes.

The top fund raisers get to attend a lunch with former Red Sox pitcher Curt Schilling.

The final score was Away 348, Home 339.

Now read that again...a group of children aged 5 to 15 spent hours of their lives playing a game. Nothing new there, but they played the game for a great reason -- other people.

This group of young citizens raised an estimated $75,000 dollars for charities.


My hat is off to these fine young folks, honestly I'm impressed with the effort & dedication it takes to do a fund raiser like this. They are supported and assisted by parents that are living their values, teaching their children to help others, not attack them. My respect goes out to the parents, the community that helped, the volunteers that made this effort such a success.

There are people who will prey on others, there are people who will help others. To the group preying on people, beware. The tide is turning again and people are starting to realize that we don't have to tolerate that behavior. To the group of people helping others, thank you for setting the example. My prayers go out that you can keep up your efforts, that your example will spread and increase, that you realize how significant you actions are.