UPDATE at the bottom-- Mike B gets his feelings all hurt in the comments and I take his comment apart. 6-27-09
Over at
MikeB's place he is having one of his usual gun crime of the day posts.
As is his norm, he's trying to spread the responsibility for some thugs shooting to everyone as much as possible.
Here is part of the story he is talking about
LAS VEGAS -- A 19-year-old Las Vegas man accepted a plea deal today in the case of a drive-by shooting that left a high school freshman dead.
Authorities said Williams drove a car while his passenger, 17-year-old Gerald Davison, shot and killed Privett as he and three friends walked home from Palo Verde High School.
In a police report, it was revealed that before the shooting, Privett and his friends got into an argument with a girl riding in Williams’ car. She told police Privett flashed a gang sign at the car, prompting Davison to shoot at them.
First, note that the victim flashed a gang sign..likely that the victim and the criminals were members of gangs. Hardly upstanding law abiding, honor students and choir boys and girls....but that is a subject for another day.
MikeB always tries to argue that as gun owners we share in the responsibility for criminal actions like this shooting. Why, you ask? Because we own gun and do not cooperate with the gun banners to remove guns from the streets.
Simply because we own firearm and don't work to pass every restrictive laws...we share responsibilty. Once again, that URL is
http://mikeb302000.blogspot.com/.
But something he said in the postcaught my eye. See if you see the logical inconsistency in his argument.
From the original post
What's interesting to me is the shared responsibility. Apparently the courts felt the older teenager who passed the gun to Davison shared in the guilt for this murder. What about the girl? The story says there was a girl in the car as well who had gotten in an argument with the dead boy earlier in the day. Does she not share in the responsibility?
Maybe there's only so much guilt to go around. Direct involvement like passing the murder weapon immediately before the incident counts, but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed. In which case, whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation.
Okay, I figure everyone got it but to make sure...here is the sentence that undermines his entire argument for our responsibility
but less direct involvement like whatever happened between the girl passenger and Privett is too far removed.
So, a person merely sitting in the car but knowing what is about to happen, a person who apparently does nothing to stop the crime -- i
s too far removed from the responsibility for the murder.
Doesn't that statement means those of us who are law abiding gun owners who don't know the criminals, who didn't break the law to sell them fireams (if any laws were broken) -- are even further removed from the responsibility in the crime?
If, as MikeB say that "
In which case,
whatever parental or societal influences might have played a factor couldn't possibly be mentioned as excuses or mitigation" than how can our responsibility be anything but so far removed as to be
NON-EXISTENT??
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Update -My reponse to MikeB's comment
MikeB,
What an absolute hypocrite you are
Bob, The repetition of the words "child pornography" by you and all your friends is becoming a bit too much for me now.
You've repeated your accusation that we are responsible for any and all firearm related crime for months now. Then when we point out an valid analogy you get pissy.
Sorry. I'm trying to discuss a sliding scale of responsibility about gun violence that I believe in and keep providing evidence and illustrations to back it up.
No, you aren't willing to provide evidence to back it up. We are trying to discuss the sliding scale of responsibility but YOU will not discuss it. You avoid it and will not take ownership of a crime when you expect us to take ownership of a crime.What utter and total hypocrisy. I'm not surprised but to have you get your nose out of joint when you've slandered gun owners for months is disgusting.You guys respond with an accusation that you don't believe in, not because you think it's so valid a comparison and necessary to make your point, but because you know I don't like it.
If you believe that if I am responsible for gun crime, then you are responsible for child porn.
Second, it is an absolutely valid comparison.
Third, how does it feel to have people make accusations about you that you don't like?
You've done this and MORE, repeatedly and without cease for almost as long as I've been reading your blog. We've explained, we've provided proof, we've provided illustrations, we've provided moral & legal arguments against your viewpoint and you low life piece of garbage have continued to make the accusations against us.
Then you have the absolute gall to try to tell me what I believe and don't believe. You have the arrogance to try to dictate what argument I should and shouldn't make...especially because it might or is hurting your little feelings!!!
And I guess some of you think you can smear my name by repeating it over and over again.
No more or no less then you are smearing the names of my friends, my family, my fellow bloggers by repeating your "theory" over and over again. Fair is fair, isn't it MikeyBoy?It's not a very admirable arguing method. It speaks volumes for you guys and for your argument
It isn't very admirable of you to continue to accuse us....but then avoiding answering the countering argument.
That is the purpose of the argument....to make you show WHY you aren't responsible for child porn-- something you've failed to do REPEATEDLY. You've just have gotten all BUTT HURT and snippy because I have found a counter to your argument.
YOU DON'T LIKE THE ARGUMENT MIKEB? PROVE IT TO BE INVALID.
Of course, the minute you prove you aren't responsible for the criminal actions of those producing child porn, you also prove we aren't responsible for the criminals misuse of firearms.
SO EITHER PROVE IT OR STOP WHINING LIKE A PRISSY 5 YEAR OLD.