Over at
MikeB's place, I've enjoyed (for the most part) discussing the issues around gun control but there is a limit. In response to a never ending stream of insuinations, accusations, distortions and sometimes out right lies, pro-freedom, pro-firearm people have tried to provide information, facts, data, legal opinions, etc to Mike.
What we get in return is more of the same. At first, I disagreed with
Weer'd Beard about the worth of continuing to debate at Mike's, now I'm completely convinced he was right.
In response to comments made on
this post Mike made the following comments
Bob says, "Sorry but your "belief" doesn't rise to the level of proof needed to deprive people of their rights."Perhaps your "belief" doesn't rise to the level of proof needed to maintain that right. Perhaps that's how "rights" are changed through history.
YGTBSM -- My proof doesn't rise to the level needed to maintain our right to keep and bear arms???
We've provided evidence from the CDC showing that firearm fatalities are declining. We've provided evidence that some countries with strict gun control laws have higher firearm homicide and crime rates while some countries with lax gun control laws have lower crime rates. In other words, no evidence that strict gun control laws work.
We've provided evidence showing that there are other factors -- social, cultural, economic, educational-- that affect crime rates more then firearm availability.
We've provided evidence showing that firearms save lives.
Over and over again, we've provided proof, sound proof that our right to keep and bear arms should not be infringed. And what does MikeB provide to back up his opinion? Quotes & sound bites from the Violence Policy Center and the Brady Campaign. Slanted stories from the left stream media.
And our proof may not be enough to keep our rights in his mind?? Abolutely frakkin amazing.
Bob also said, "I know, I know you say you don't want to stop good people from having firearms, but how can you reduce availability and still let good people have firearms."One way is to redefine what we mean by "good people." Obviously the definition we've been working with is not working. As much as you deny it, the flow of these so-called "good" gun owners over to the dark side is significant.
We've provided evidence, time and time again, showing that the "flow" of guns is insignificant.
The
Bureau of Justice Statistics report 419,640 for 2005. The
CDC reported 12,352 fatalities related to firearm homicides in the same year.
Estimates place the number of firearms in America around 280,000,000. Even allowing for every firearm to be a new and unique firearm used in crime, that means only 0.15428% of all firearms were used in crimes in 2005. Hardly significant! That type of irrationality can not be swayed by the facts, by the truth.
This was the final straw -
One way is to redefine what we mean by "good people."
So, what does MikeB propose to do? Redefine every gun owner as "bad people"? Despite the evidence that gun owners are by and large law abiding, despite the fact that most firearm related crimes are committed by people who have criminal records (and most gun owners don't have a criminal record) MikeB wants to take away our rights.
It really isn't that far of a step to imagine that as not good people our rights will be completely trampled to reduce the availability of firearms. Never mind that no prohibition, no ban has ever stopped the flow of an item, we see MikeB's eventual goal in these words....the confiscation of firearms from the law abiding.
So enough is enough, I'm mostly done with this troll. I'll raid his site for occasional blog fodder but I won't be commenting on a regular basis there. I'll post my replies and thoughts on this blog where I know that my comments won't be moderated out of existence.
/rant off